The highly anticipated second season of 1923 debuted on Paramount+, bringing not only new storylines but also a heartfelt tribute to the late Cole Brings Plenty. The young actor, known for his role as Pete Plenty Clouds, passed away in April 2024, leaving behind a legacy of powerful performances and a promising future in the industry. To honor his contributions, the show’s premiere opened with an In Memoriam dedication featuring his image, ensuring his presence was felt even in his absence.
Cole Brings Plenty’s Legacy in 1923
Cole Brings Plenty played Pete Plenty Clouds in 1923 Season 1, a character whose journey intertwined with that of Teonna Rainwater (Aminah Nieves) and her father, Runs His Horse (Michael Spears). His role was set to expand in Season 2, making his unexpected passing all the more heartbreaking for fans and the 1923 cast alike. As the nephew of Yellowstone star Mo Brings Plenty, he carried a deep connection to the franchise and the Indigenous storytelling it sought to amplify.
Brings Plenty was known for his dedication to his craft, and his portrayal of Pete was praised for its depth and authenticity. His presence in the Yellowstone universe highlighted the importance of Indigenous representation in mainstream television, adding weight to the show’s historical narrative.
Tragic Passing and Its Impact on 1923
The actor’s death was met with shock and sorrow across the entertainment industry. He was reported missing on April 2, 2024, and found deceased three days later in a rural Kansas area. While authorities ruled out foul play, his family has since called for further investigation into the circumstances surrounding his passing. His death not only left an emotional void among his loved ones but also raised questions about the need for transparency in high-profile cases.
With Brings Plenty’s absence, the 1923 team was faced with the delicate challenge of continuing Pete Plenty Clouds’ story. The showrunners made the difficult decision to recast the role, choosing Jeremy Guana, an actor familiar to fans of the Yellowstone universe from his previous work in 1883.
Jeremy Guana Steps Into the Role
Jeremy Guana now portrays Pete Plenty Clouds in 1923 Season 2, a choice that has been met with understanding and support from fans and cast members alike. Aminah Nieves, who plays Teonna Rainwater, spoke about the recasting and Guana’s approach to the role. In an interview at the 1923 premiere, she reflected on how Guana was not only a talented actor but also a close friend of Brings Plenty. She emphasized that his performance was deeply influenced by his respect for his late colleague and the responsibility of carrying forward Pete’s story in a way that honored Brings Plenty’s legacy.
A Tribute Beyond the Screen
The tribute to Brings Plenty in 1923‘s Season 2 premiere was more than just a symbolic gesture; it was a heartfelt recognition of his talent, dedication, and impact. The In Memoriam dedication that appeared at the beginning of the episode ensured that his memory was preserved within the series he loved.
Additionally, the cast and crew have expressed their ongoing support for Brings Plenty’s family, with Paramount+ executives acknowledging his contributions to the show.
The Importance of Indigenous Representation in 1923
Brings Plenty’s presence in 1923 was significant beyond just his performance. As a Native American actor, he was part of a broader effort to ensure that Indigenous stories were told authentically within the Yellowstone universe. His role, as well as that of his on-screen father Hank Plenty Clouds (Michael Greyeyes), added depth to the show’s portrayal of the struggles faced by Indigenous communities in the early 20th century.
His passing serves as a reminder of the challenges that Indigenous actors face in the industry and the importance of continuing to create spaces where their stories can be told with accuracy and respect. By honoring Brings Plenty’s memory, 1923 reinforces its commitment to Indigenous representation and storytelling.
Moving Forward
As 1923 Season 2 progresses, Pete Plenty Clouds’ story will continue with Jeremy Guana stepping into the role. While fans may feel the absence of Brings Plenty, his impact on the show will never be forgotten. His dedication to his craft and his contributions to 1923 will continue to be celebrated by those who worked with him and those who admired his performances.
Though his time was tragically cut short, Cole Brings Plenty’s presence in 1923 remains indelible. His legacy as an actor and advocate for Indigenous representation will endure, ensuring that his work is remembered and cherished for years to come.
